With its mesquite-grilled steaks, slow-roasted prime rib and St. Louis-style barbecue pork ribs, the Metropolitan Grill has got what it takes to feed entire packs of carnivores. Even the house martini defers to the kitchen, in a way: It's made with Beefeater Gin. Go, enjoy and keep your fingers crossed that your vegan significant other doesn't find out.
You also mentioned...
Buenos Aires Grill, Pecos Pit BBQ, Palace Kitchen, Union Square Grill, Smokin' Pete's BBQ, Canlis, Tony Roma's, "umm ... my parents" (you ate your parents?!) and "nowhere!"