In this corner: The Jones, a rising star on the bistro scene that offers such sweet potions as the vanilla vodka- and coconut rum-infused "Key Lime Pie." In the other corner: Last year's winner The Chapel Bar, which serves martinis flavored with honeydew, lavender and even banana. Your votes have these two mighty competitors in a tie – so needless to say, you and your friends have some tasting to do if you ever want this battle resolved.