While highly-touted newcomer Volterra duked it out with Angelina's Trattoria, The Cellar quietly and authoritatively took first place. Good thing, too. This Capitol Hill hideaway is known for its lush take on classic Northern Italian cuisine like Penne Fromaggi. The House Made Meat Lasagna would make your nonna blush. The stuffed Chicken Serrano Scallops Piccata are cose di bellezza. The prices and service, like the food and ambience, are extremely inviting.